| Joseph Twichell House – demolished. Joseph Twichell and his family rented this house for many years before the Asylum Hill Congregational Society purchased it and presented it to him as a 50th birthday present. |
| Extant – private apartments. Asylum Hill Congregational Church Parsonage, 1912-1932. The Asylum Hill Congregational Society purchased this house to serve as its parsonage after Joseph Twichell retired. Only two senior pastors occupied it: John Voorhees and Willis Butler. |
| Extant – private residence. Asylum Hill Congregational Church Parsonage, 1932-1965. It served as the home for David McKeith and Bernard Drew, the third and fourth senior pastors of the church. |